9 September 2005

Water, fire and colour - 1

Hurricane Katrina has me going red with rage. You ask why? I'll tell you why. Last week, just as soon as it happened, there was some reporter on TV, live from the US, talking about the (then sorry, now horrific) state of affairs in New Orleans. And he goes "New Orleans looks like a third world state today - no electricity, no food, no water,".

First off, what is a third world state? I've heard of third world countries (who the hell decides what is a third world country, anyways? The pompous and affluent first and second worlds, for sure). And what did he mean by no water, electricity etc. Does he honestly believe that in India for example, we have no access to things like power and water? I couldn't believe how ignorant and how complacent he was. Only the darkest of the dark parts in the world, probably has a situation as bad as no electicity or water or whatever, everywhere. Oh, ignorance in that reporter's case was definitely not my cup of bliss.

*********************

And talking of Katrina, the aftermath was so similar to a disaster anywhere in the world _ the crying, distress, hopelessness, looting, raping etc. So what does that prove? That the Americans, in spite of all their affluence and wealth, are just as desperate as their counterparts in any other part of the world. It's all very well to be nice and polished and glamourous and advanced when things are hunky-dory. But it's when the chips are down that you need to see how people behave to know what they are really like. And in this case, our wonderful Yanks have proved that they are in no way superior to their Indian cousins. They are only human, after all.

Don't get me wrong, I am not gloating. Far from it! I find the sight of the suffering there so moving, I can barely watch it sometimes and have to switch off the TV. But this is definitely a slap in the face of all those (media included) who pointed all fingers at India when the tsunami and then the Mumbai flooding happened. How can India (even dare to) hope to become a superpower with such pathetic infrastructure, was one question they all unfailingly asked.

And I say, Mumbai rains were once-in-a-90-years incident. Hurricanes in the US are not _ they are part of daily life there. And yet, despite the advanced disaster management systems that US has access to, relief was so slow and so inadquate. And the US is already a super-power and has been so for decades now.

*******************

And to me, the worst was the open show of racism. Many whites evacuated to safety while the blacks suffered in the Superbowl. Down south in the US, old habits still die hard.

So, in India, we have religion. In the US and the West, we have colour and race. And so much wealth. After all, we are talking the country that gave the world capitalism and commercialism. And still, the bottom line is the same. Makes me think: what was the US like after 50-odd years of liberation from the Brits? And what will India be like, 200 years after our Independence. Although in my mind, I am sure of the result.

............To be concluded (wait for it, folks!)

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

So true.(I wanted to blog about the same thing earlier, but am soo busy, that I just cant get to it)... when there's a calamity every place is the same... but the thing here was that aid, rescuing etc I believe took a long time to come in. Not to mention the number of crimes like looting etc. I got a forward comparing it to the recent Mumbai rains - and the one thing I am so proud of is that there were no cases of such crimes in Mumbai like what happened after Katrina. In fact I saw pictures of Indian women distributing food/snacks to stranded people in Mumbai, wada walas were giving away wadas to folks who were stuck - that is the mumbai and Indian spirit... the media may keep going on with its usual crap about caste and religion, but India has shown its unity during the Mumbai rains. Jai Hind! We have shown the world what we're made of.

I am really sorry for the people of New Orleans - when nature shows it's fury there's so much that we lose ... I pray for the victims and their families..may God give the survivors strength ...

Vid

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Absolutely Jai Hind and Jai Bharat, Vidhu.
When it is an act of God, not really much left that man can do. Go well.

Shammi said...

What I found scary was comments from Southern Americans on the BBC site, re an article that a BBC correspondent had written about the debacle in New Orleans. Things to the effect that Americans dont discriminate in helping on the basis of colour, they dont need the world's help, they will take care of their own, and that anybody criticising how the aftermath was handled is blind to America's good points and hates Bush's govt. Yikes.

Unknown said...

I agree with your point on third world. Rating must be on human values rather than on material values. I have stopped watching TVs instead I go out talk to people.

loloma said...

Hi Lakshmi and sorry for posting comments out of the blue. I don't really remember how I came across your blog, but it was a strange coincidence, coz I was reading your post about Katrina (nodding in agreement), then heard Sheryl Crow singing in the background on the radio:

'Fire rages in the streets
And swallows everything it meets
It’s just an image often seen
On television
Come leaders, come you men of great
Let us hear you pontificate
Your many virtues laid to waste
And we aren’t listening
What do you have for us today
Throw us a bone but save the plate
On why we waited til so late
Was there no oil to excavate
No riches in trade for the fate
Of every person who died in hate
Throw us a bone, you men of great...'


Thought it pretty much sums up everything :(

Anonymous said...

Lakshmi,Really enjoyed your blog! Keep it up!
Looks like 'anyways' has gained general acceptance.Cheers, Raghu

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Shyam,

I think it's part of the whole set-up, it just stinks and not just literally in New Orleans. Makes me feel that we humans are a sad race!

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Macmohan,

Welcome to my blog. And I absolutely agree with you. India has a lot going for it, esply with half the population being young.

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Loloma,

No worries, you are welcome. Sheryl Crow has in this case summed it all up. I only hope and pray that we don't have ocassion to quote her lyrics again.

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Raghu,

Good to see you on my blog and keep coming often. As for anyways, I tend to use it anyways, whether or not it is accepted*grin*. cheers.

Anonymous said...

Lakshmi, I should agree with your comment on America playing the biggest part in polluting and dirtying the planet. For that matter they are responsible for all the horrific things happening in the world. They think they are superpower! How clever!!!
Gayathri

Castor aka Kiwilax said...

Gayathri,

Good to see your comment. Yes the US does have too good an opinion of itself. While I don't dispute that it does go some good, by and large, they are just big bullies!